Sarah Smythe
Sara 21
The Young and the Restless
Portrayed by Tracey E. Bregman
Current status Former, Contract
Duration 2010
Family Smythe
Gender Female
Sarah Smythe
Tracey E. Bregman as Sarah Smythe, after Sarah had a plastic surgery to look like Lauren Fenmore.
Parents Molly Carter (mother)
Siblings Sheila Carter (sister)
Spouses Joshua Smythe (1981-1993)
Nieces and
Erica Lovejoy
Diana Carter
Ryder Callahan
Daisy Carter
Sarah Smythe is a fictional character on The Young and the Restless, portrayed by Tracey E. Bregman.


Sarah is the youngest daughter of Molly Carter and therefore the younger sister of Sheila Carter.

According to Sarah's report, when Sheila became obsessed with torturing Lauren Fenmore she gave Sarah twin babies, Daisy Sanders and Ryder Callahan, to raise. (It's unknown what happened to Mary Carter Warwick and Diana Carter (The Bold and the Beautiful), Sheila's other daughters.) Sheila died not too long after that. Deacon Sharpe came to town to torture Amber Moore and Daniel Romalotti. Deacon's reign of terror didn't last too long and he was arrested. In jail he explained to Amber that he had to torture them or else a "Dragon Lady" would hurt his son. Daisy and Ryder came to town.Daisy lured jana hawkes (who figured out that Ryder and daisy were twins )to a theatre and daisy knocked here out and kidnapped her . Daisy befriended Lauren while Ryder was the outcast. Daisy was drugging Lauren and tried to ruin her marriage all while communicating with a woman she called "Mama Bear". Lauren realized the truth about Daisy, and she and Ryder were arrested. Sarah (aka Mama Bear) bailed them out. They went to the annual charity masquerade ball at the Genoa City Athletic Club, kidnapped Lauren and locked her in a cage at the zoo with Jana Hawkes.

Jana had been missing for a few months. Kevin heard someone calling his name from the zoo, the same place that when he did the ouiji board spelled out with Gloria and Jeffrey. Lauren thought Sarah was Sheila, but Sarah came around and Sarah showed up and looked exactly like Lauren. Lauren was horrifed to see that Sarah had stolen her face. Sarah explained that she was out for revenge for everyone who ruined Sheila's life, claiming to be her sister. Sarah planned to take over Lauren's life, but it wasn't so easy. Lauren's young son, Fenmore Baldwin, knew something was wrong (like when she read him his and Lauren's favorite bedtime story and she saw spider and smashed the book shut )and Lauren's husband, Michael Baldwin, was suspisious. Sarah plotted with Patty Williams, who had drugged and taken over the life of Emily Peterson, to kill the threats to their plans: Patty would kill Michael and Sarah would kill Phyllis Newman. Sarah tried to strangle Phyllis, but Phyllis jumped in a closet and slammed the door on Sarah's arm.phyllis baracaded herself in her penthouse and Michael came in and they called "lauren"and Lauren said "she was leaving.phyllis noticed that it was pop go the wealsle so they drove to the amusement park . Sarah ran back to the zoo only to find that Ryder had released Jana and Lauren. Sarah chased them on to a merry-go-round and saw Jana's husband, Kevin Fisher, who thought she was Lauren. She tried to shoot him, but missed.kevin managed to get the gun out of here hand and briefly knock here out . Lauren knew Sarah wanted her so in order to protect Jana she ran in the opposite direction and Sarah followed,but Daisy held Kevin at gun point and but managed to escape to a nere by helicopter with murph and Katherine and explained everything.

They ended up in a house of mirrors with Sarah shooting at the mirrors, confused by the reflections. Michael walked in and left phyllis in the car because she had a Brocken leg and wanted her more than Michael . Sarah and Lauren tried to convince him who was the real Lauren, and Lauren recited her marriage vows. She then got the gun away from Sarah, Phyllis said the password "karma " and responded its a bitch, and then Lauren shot Sarah. Phyllis figured out that it really was Sarah because Sarah had a gash on her arm that Phyllis spotted when Sarah tried to strangle her. Sarah is then declared dead at the scene, but Sarah survived the shot and she underwent plastic surgery operation to reconstruct her face.